EDR vs. AV: The Complete Guide to Modern Endpoint Security

As businesses try to stay ahead of the curve in cybersecurity, they continue to face threats from malicious actors trying to breach sensitive data and operations. Proper endpoint security selection is, therefore, essential for strong protection. Of the many types of endpoint security, there are two popular types: EDR and traditional antivirus. 

Although each has its advantages, functionality, and effectiveness are miles apart. Let's take a look at these differences so you can make an informed decision about the best choice for your organization's needs.

Understanding Antivirus: Traditional Defense Against Known Threats

Antivirus is one of the most known solutions for the protection of computers against malware. It primarily works by detection and removal of malware from files, programs, and network traffic.

How Does Antivirus Work? Signature-Based Detection

Antivirus software mainly relies on a database of known virus signatures. The software scans files, applications, and incoming data against this database, flagging any matches. This works well against known malware but fails against new and evolving threats.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Antivirus

Advantages:

• Cost-effective and user-friendly.

• Efficient at blocking known threats.

• Typically lightweight, using minimal system resources.

Disadvantages:

• Limited effectiveness against zero-day threats and sophisticated malware.

• Minimal response capabilities for active attacks.

• Little or no support for threat analysis and forensics.

Who Should Consider Antivirus?

Antivirus is a better fit for small businesses or individuals who require basic protection only. It can also be useful when cases of common malware types appear, and it is also relatively easy to use, requiring little expertise in IT.

What is EDR? Advanced Threat Detection and Response

More than the conventional antivirus approach, EDR provides detection and response against cyber threats. It watches endpoint activities in real-time, marking unusual behaviors and responding as soon as it detects some potential threats.

How Does EDR Work? Behavioural Analysis and Real-Time Monitoring

EDR differs significantly from the way that antivirus will scan a machine with traditional signature-based detection. A detection of malicious behavior that involves using both behavioral analytics and machine learning, ensures the EDR detects potential threats not present in well-known signatures and proves more proficient in fighting against APTs and zero-day threats.

Main Characteristics of EDR

• Threat Discovery: In real-time detection, the EDR determines any abnormal activity within a specific endpoint.

• Forensic: The EDR outlines information regarding threats' points of origin as well as vectors of attacks.

• Automated Response Capabilities: EDR can isolate endpoints, block malicious activity, and initiate remediation.

Benefits and Drawbacks of EDR

Benefits:

• Best detection of new, unknown, and advanced threats.

• Endpoint activities are highly visible.

• Active threat response, including containment and remediation.

Disadvantages:

• Generally costlier and resource-intensive.

• Requires a trained IT staff to implement and manage properly.

• It consumes more system resources than traditional antivirus.

Who Should Implement EDR?

EDR is best suited for large organizations with high-value assets and sensitive data. Companies that require real-time threat detection and response capabilities, especially those in regulated industries like finance or healthcare, would benefit most from EDR.

Detailed Comparison: EDR vs. Antivirus

Understanding the specific differences between EDR and antivirus solutions is essential to selecting the right protection for your business. Below are key factors to consider:

• Detection Methodologies: Signature-Based vs. Behavioral Analysis

Threat detection by the antivirus makes use of known malware signature-based libraries, but EDR uses behavioral analysis and also machine learning and is therefore highly responsive to threats that it has not experienced or discovered before.

• Response to Identified Threats

In essence, antivirus is reactive in a measure because it will only start acting once a known threat has been established. Conversely, EDR measures have proactive tendencies to actions by providing isolation and containment. It can instantaneously take action on identified threats.

• Real-Time Monitoring and Threat Intelligence

While antivirus software typically scans cyclically, EDR solutions will monitor endpoints continuously to alert for real-time detection as well as provide threat intelligence for any identified threats.

• Scope of Protection: Light Malware versus Advanced Malware

Simple Malware antivirus tools handle light malware. EDR, on the other hand, is designed for neutralizing advanced, multi-step malware threats, especially fileless malware and advanced persistent threats.

• Automation and Remediation Capabilities

EDR can automatically execute remedies that include quarantining files isolating them from the rest or taking remedial measures. Antivirus generally waits for human intervention for its remedies.

• View and Manage the End Point Endpoint

EDR will monitor all details of your endpoint involving its behavior and lifecycle as this will be very productive for use in many phases of incident response in a firm.

Resource Requirements: IT Expertise, Costs, and Maintenance

• IT Expertise: Compared with the antivirus, EDR requires much more IT expertise to deploy and maintain a continued support requirement.

• Cost: There is yet another factor of the cost it has expenses to it, which is directly associated with not-so-the simplest IT expertise that demands in an organization in various cases. 

Read the Latest

NIST Cybersecurity Framework: A Risk-Based Approach

Consider Now to Make the Right One

The decision-making aspect between choosing an EDR versus an antivirus varies in many aspects that distinguish organizations. Among the very basic considerations are the following:-

• Cost Factor

Antiviruses cost less to manage, as EDR software is highly priced due to sophisticated features.

• Business Entity and Endpoint Scale

Where in case the business units involved are too large and also have thousands of endpoints it is EDR more of a required solution.

• Availability of IT Resources and Cybersecurity Expertise

Organizations with a dedicated IT security team are better equipped to handle the complexity of EDR, whereas antivirus can be managed with less expertise.

• Real-Time Response Requirements

If real-time detection and response are critical, then EDR's active monitoring and automated responses make it the better choice.

How InterSources Inc. Can Help

InterSources Inc. offers traditional antivirus solutions up to the latest EDR solutions to businesses from all walks of life. This is how we assist organizations through every phase of their journey: 

• Security Assessment and Solution Recommendation.

Our experts begin by ensuring a proper security assessment of the environment, assets, and security requirements. From there, we can proceed to recommend the best-fit solution for your business, whether it is antivirus EDR or a combination of both.

• Solution Implementation and Training

We take care of everything related to the implementation of the solution, from configuration to endpoint integration and staff training. Our team ensures a smooth transition so that your IT teams are free to execute their new solution effectively.

• Continuous Threat Monitoring and Management

Managed cybersecurity services include continuous monitoring, proactive threat intelligence, and timely updates to make sure that your systems stay secure against emerging threats.

• Incident Response and Support

In the event of a cyber incident, we can provide quick response, including containment of threats and impact minimization. Our incident response services include forensics, recovery, and post-incident analysis to strengthen your defenses.

Transition from Antivirus to EDR

Transitioning from antivirus to EDR for an organization is not a one-day job and requires proper planning and execution. Here's how you can approach this process:

• Assess Security Needs and Identify Gaps

Evaluate your current antivirus weaknesses and determine what needs additional security layers, like real-time threat detection.

• Select the Right Vendor and Solution

Select a vendor that has EDR success stories in your industry. Make sure the EDR solution will have a seamless integration with your current security infrastructure.

• Phased Rollout

Implement EDR in phases. Roll out the solution first in risky departments or endpoints and extend it progressively until all the endpoints are covered.

• Training and Onboarding

All IT teams responsible for managing EDR must have proper training. Security awareness among the end-users can reduce dangerous behavior.

• Track Success and Analyze Performance

Evaluate EDR performance by periodic metrics like response time, threat detection rates, and endpoint visibility.

Case Studies

Below is an example of how different organizations can deploy antivirus or EDR solutions:

Examples:-

1: Small Business Selecting Antivirus

A small retail business with scarce IT resources selects antivirus because it is relatively cheap. The antivirus will block the common type of malware very effectively but will require it to be upgraded when the business grows.

2: Large Corporation Embracing EDR

A multinational company having sensitive financial information implements EDR due to its effective threat detection capabilities. This EDR helps the organization to meet compliance standards besides providing real-time monitoring capabilities.

3: Hybrid Approach

A healthcare organization of mid-size requires antivirus for general protection besides using EDR for critical systems handling patient data. As a result, the risk of security breaches is provided through a layered approach to security.

4: Compliance-Driven EDR in Healthcare

A healthcare provider has to adhere to HIPAA, hence, they adopt EDR. This way, they can maintain all their logs and be HIPAA compliant.

5: Bank Upgrade from Antivirus to EDR

Bank which used antivirus upgradings to EDR about the sophisticated threats targeting the customer data and financial systems. The upgrading will help in proactive defense and provide detailed threat intelligence.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What's the difference between EDR and Antivirus?

While antivirus runs a known signature database to detect and block threats, EDR monitors for and responds to real-time threats by enabling proactive defense against emerging threats. EDR uses behavioral analysis; it is better suited to sophisticated, unknown threats whereas an antivirus is best suited for simple, known malware.

2. Can antivirus and EDR be used in tandem?

Yes, it can be combined as a layered security approach, and antivirus protects against more common malware, while EDR adds advanced detection and response capabilities for unknown and sophisticated threats, enhancing overall security. 

3. Is EDR suitable for small businesses?

Advanced protection from EDR will be welcome for small businesses dealing with sensitive information or that have regulatory requirements. However, for those companies, whose security needs are not complex, a traditional antivirus is probably enough. EDR is notoriously resource-intensive and requires a dedicated IT team.

4. What is the approach of EDR against zero-day threats?

The case of EDR detection of zero-day threats, as it analyzes the behaviors or patterns instead of making use of any pre-known signatures. At an advanced level using machine learning, it identifies suspicious activities related to a zero-day attack which enables it to react at a very fast pace to new unidentified threats.

5. What are the core costs associated with EDR?

EDR tends to have much steeper prices compared to other regular antivirus, mainly based on the enhanced functionalities they possess. That might, in many cases, point to installation or start-up fees, license purchase costs, constant scanning of the monitoring, and perhaps other dedicated IT skills running the system. While expensive to companies in many instances can be quite unattractive, their defense is rated to be much more boosted than the normal anti-antivirus tools.

6. In what way does EDR improve upon incident response capabilities?

EDR delivers real-time monitoring, detailed threat intelligence, and even automated responses. In case EDR detects a threat, it can isolate affected endpoints, quarantine malicious files, and initiate remediation actions, therefore, minimizing the response time as much as possible in comparison with traditional antivirus.

7. Do I need dedicated IT to manage EDR?

Although some EDR solutions are designed to be user-friendly, managing EDR well requires skilled IT staff. Managed EDR services offered by vendors such as InterSources Inc. allow companies to outsource monitoring and management and avoid a full-time in-house team to achieve compliance.

8. Can EDR solutions help with compliance?

Yes, EDR solutions can be used for compliance through granular logging, reporting, and forensic capabilities, which are helpful in the case of regulatory audits. For finance and healthcare industries, EDR provides excellent monitoring and data protection functionalities that help in compliance with HIPAA, GDPR, and PCI-DSS frameworks.

9. How does EDR impact system performance compared to antivirus?

The main reason EDR solutions consume more system resources than traditional products is that they are constantly monitoring and processing data. However, most EDR vendors optimize the solution to reduce its potential performance impact, and some EDRs even offer the ability to balance protection with performance.

10. How do I know if my business should switch from antivirus to EDR?

If your business has more complex threats, demands a detailed incident response, or is in a highly regulated industry, EDR would be the better fit. Take into account endpoint visibility, compliance needs, or IT resources, or explore our cybersecurity services.